Do Instagram Giveaways Really Grow Followers? (And How to Keep Them)
Insta Picker is the Free Instagram Comment Picker for Giveaways, Pick fair winners from public Instagram comments with duplicate, mention, and keyword filters.
The quick answer
Do Instagram giveaways increase followers? Yes — your follower count will rise while the giveaway runs, and a noticeable share of those new followers will leave in the days after it ends. Whether the giveaway was worth it depends on what is left a month later: followers who actually care about what you post.
That is the honest answer, and it is the whole post in one paragraph. A giveaway is a fast way to be discovered. It is not, on its own, a way to build an audience that stays. The difference between a giveaway that grows your account and one that only inflates a number for a week comes down to three things: the prize, the entry rules, and what you post after the winner is announced.
Pick a winner now — free, no Instagram login.
Why your follower count rises, then falls
During a giveaway, three things push your follower count up. People follow you because following is a condition of entry. People who would never have found your account see it because entrants tag their friends. And Instagram shows your post to more people because comments and shares rise.
Then the giveaway ends, and the same logic runs in reverse. The prize is gone, so the reason to follow is gone. Entrants who followed only to enter unfollow, sometimes within hours of the winner being announced. People who followed a friend's tag and never looked at your content again do the same, more slowly, over the following weeks.
This is normal, and it happens to every giveaway, including well-run ones. The question is never whether you will lose some of the new followers. It is how many you keep, and whether the ones you keep are the right people.
What decides whether new followers stay
Followers stay for one reason: they want to see more of what you post. Everything else is a detail. That is why the prize matters more than any other choice you make.
A prize your audience wants
Give away something your ideal follower would want even without a giveaway. A bakery giving away a cake-decorating class keeps followers who like baking. The same bakery giving away a new phone gains followers who like phones — and they will leave the moment the phone is gone, because nothing else on the account interests them.
The test is simple: would someone who wins this prize be glad they followed you? If the answer is no, the prize is wrong for your account, however popular it looks. The best giveaway prizes are your own product, your own service, or something closely tied to your niche. If you need a starting point, browse Instagram giveaway prize ideas and pick one that fits your audience, not the widest audience.
Entry rules that filter for real interest
Entry rules decide who enters, and therefore who follows you. A rule that anyone can complete in two seconds — comment an emoji — brings in everyone, including people who will never look at your account again. A rule that takes a little thought brings in people who are at least a little interested.
Ask entrants to answer a real question, or to tag friends who would genuinely like the prize. A keyword or a short answer takes effort, and effort is a filter. It also gives you something to check when you draw the winner, instead of a pile of identical emoji comments. When the giveaway closes, run the draw with InstaPicker so the winner comes from the filtered entries, not from a pile of duplicate comments.
One rule to be careful with: requiring entrants to follow several accounts at once. Instagram loop giveaways can grow every account in the loop quickly, but they also produce the fastest unfollows, because many entrants followed ten accounts they had no interest in. If you join a loop, expect the drop-off to be steep, and do not count loop followers as lasting growth.
What you post in the week after the giveaway
The week after the winner is announced is when most unfollows happen, and it is also when you have the most new eyes on your account. Post your best work that week — the kind of post that made your existing followers follow you in the first place. If a new follower's first impression of your account is a week of silence, or a run of sales posts, there is no reason to stay.
Welcome the new followers, too. A Story that says the giveaway is over, thanks everyone who entered, and shows what is coming next gives new followers a reason to stick around for at least one more post. That one more post is often the difference between a follower who stays and one who leaves.
The followers you do not want
Not all follower growth is good growth, and some of it actively hurts your account. Bots and fake accounts that enter giveaways inflate your follower count with accounts that never engage, never buy, and never watch your content. A large follower count with very low engagement makes your account look worse to real visitors, and to Instagram's ranking, than a smaller count with real engagement.
Watch for the signs while the giveaway runs: a sudden jump in followers with no matching rise in likes or comments, new followers with empty profiles, or dozens of new followers from accounts that only enter giveaways. None of these is a reason to cancel the giveaway, but they are a reason to be honest about what the follower count means. A giveaway that gained you 500 followers, of which 200 were real and interested, was a better result than one that gained you 2,000 followers, of which 100 were real.
How to measure what the giveaway actually gained you
Do not judge a giveaway by the follower count on the day the winner is announced. That number is the peak, not the result. Measure it properly instead.
- Record your follower count the day before the giveaway starts. This is your baseline. Everything after it is measured against this number, not against zero.
- Record it again on the day the winner is announced. The difference is your gross gain — the largest number, and the least meaningful one.
- Record it again seven days later, and again thirty days later. The thirty-day number, minus the baseline, is your net gain. That is the number that matters.
- Check engagement, not just followers. Did your average likes and comments per post rise after the giveaway, or did they stay flat while the follower count rose? If engagement stayed flat, the new followers are not watching.
- Work out the cost per kept follower. Divide what the giveaway cost — the prize, the shipping, your time — by the net gain at thirty days. That is the real price of each follower you kept, and it is the number to compare against your next giveaway, or against any other way of growing.
If you want a simple way to run those numbers, the giveaway ROI calculator on this site lets you enter the prize cost and the results and see whether the giveaway paid for itself.
What to do differently next time
If your last giveaway grew your count and then lost most of it, the fix is rarely to run a bigger giveaway. It is to change one of the three things that decide retention.
First, make the prize narrower, not bigger. A prize worth less, but aimed exactly at your audience, will bring fewer entrants and keep more of them. Second, make the entry rule ask for a little more thought — a real answer instead of an emoji, a tag of a real friend instead of anyone. Third, plan the week after the giveaway before you launch it, so your best content meets the new followers while they are still looking.
And pick a prize you would be happy to give to a follower. When the winner is announced, the people who did not win should still be glad they found your account. That is the real test of whether a giveaway grows followers: not how many people followed to enter, but how many stayed because they liked what they found.
Pick a winner now — free, no Instagram login.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, a giveaway raises your follower count while it runs, because following is a condition of entry and entrants tag friends. Many of those new followers leave after the winner is announced, so the real gain is what remains after a month.
They followed to enter, not because they wanted your content, so the reason to follow disappears the moment the prize is gone. The drop is steepest when the prize had nothing to do with your niche, because the followers had no reason to stay.
A prize your ideal follower would want even without a giveaway, such as your own product, your own service, or something closely tied to your niche. A generic prize like a phone attracts prize hunters who leave as soon as the draw is over.
Loop giveaways grow every account in the loop quickly, because entrants must follow all of them to enter. Most of those followers leave fast, because they followed ten accounts they had no interest in, so count loop growth as temporary, not lasting.
Record your follower count the day before the giveaway, on the day the winner is announced, and seven and thirty days later. The thirty-day count minus your baseline is your net gain, and comparing it with your engagement shows whether the followers are watching.